Genes, environments & behaviors
Our large brains are surely at the center of our humanity. But it is equally certain that few organs are the subject of more misinformation in scientific and public discourse鈥揺specially in the widespread notion that most behaviors controlled by our marvelous brain are somehow programmed into it genetically. A typical treatment in the popular press is this overexcited claim by columnist Nicholas Wade in the New York Times: 鈥淲hen . . . [the human genome] . . . is fully translated, it will prove the ultimate thriller鈥搕he indisputable guide to the graces and horrors of human nature, the creations and cruelties of the human mind, the unbearable light and darkness of being.鈥1
Wade may get a pass for being a journalist, but some scientists are equally confused. Molecular biologist Dean Hamer wrote: 鈥淧eople are different because they have different genes that created different brains that formed different personalities,鈥 and 鈥淸u]nderstanding the genetic roots of personality will help you 鈥榝ind yourself鈥 and relate better to others.鈥 As distinguished a neurobiologist as Michael Gazzaniga is guilty of the misleading claim that 鈥渁ll behavioral traits are heritable鈥;2 and molecular evolutionists Roderick Page and Edward Holmes have asserted that 鈥済enes control 62% of our cognitive ability.鈥3 In fact, an entire neo-field labeled evolutionary psychology has sprung up based on the misconception that genes are somehow determining our everyday behavior and our personalities. It is a field that believes there are genetic evolutionary answers to such questions as why a man driving an expensive car is more attractive than one driving a cheap car.4
. . .