When the mind leaves the body... and returns
I am sitting with a colleague on a platform at the front of a large university lecture hall. We are psychologists teaching in the same department, brought together on this occasion by students who want to hear how we converse. It is a Monday evening in the middle of the term, and the lecture hall is filled. We each speak briefly about our work and then begin the conversation. I notice that when I say 鈥渧oice,鈥 my colleague, who studies cognition and intelligence, responds by saying 鈥渢he notion of voice鈥 or 鈥渢he metaphor of voice.鈥 I move my chair away from his to signal the gap that has opened between us. The next morning, in class, my students want to talk about what happened. I write the word 鈥榲oice鈥 on the blackboard, the sound sibilant in the still, morning air. One after another the students respond: 鈥淭he notion of voice, the metaphor of voice.鈥 We talk about what happens when the body drops out of the conversation.
I am sitting with Sundi at a small table in an empty classroom of her public school. She is eleven, in the sixth grade, and a member of the writing and theater club that meets on Tuesday afternoons, part of a three-year project designed to strengthen healthy resistance and courage in girls. It is spring in the second year of the project, and I am interviewing Sundi. I place a photograph on the table in front of her and ask her to tell a story about what is happening. She stares into the face of the girl in the picture and says the girl has just had a fight with her friend鈥搒he is angry and sad. 鈥淲here is the anger?鈥 I ask. Sundi replies: 鈥淚n the pit of her stomach and in her throat.鈥 And the sadness? 鈥淭he sadness is in her heart.鈥
At age nine, Judy says that she knows how her friend will feel because 鈥淚 just feel it in my mind.鈥 When she sees someone walking away from her best friend, leaving her alone 鈥渏ust talking into space,鈥 she does not infer how her friend will feel or put herself in her friend鈥檚 place. Instead, she says, 鈥淵ou can just kind of see them walking away or getting sad or something, but you can鈥檛 tell right then and there she鈥檚 going to get hurt or anything鈥揵ut you just feel it. It鈥檚 hard to explain.鈥 There is little language for this emotional connectedness and the knowing to which it gives rise. . . .
Access the full volume here.